Health information to help you understand symptoms. It isn't a diagnosis.
Check symptoms

Research deep dives

Cartilage repair: what the operations actually do

Last reviewed November 17, 2026. OwieClear editorial team. Waiting for clinician review. Not medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your own care.

When a fragment cannot be saved, the surgeon is left with a hole in a joint surface and a choice of imperfect ways to fill it.

None restores normal cartilage. Understanding what each technique actually produces makes the trade-offs legible.

Related pages: Osteochondritis dissecans (loose piece of bone in a joint)

The bottom line

What we know
  • No technique restores normal articular cartilage.
  • Microfracture produces fibrocartilage, which is less durable.
  • Osteochondral autograft moves real cartilage but is limited by donor supply.
  • Allograft suits larger defects and uses donor tissue.
  • Cell-based repair involves two operations and long rehabilitation.
What is still open
  • Which technique is best for which defect.
  • How durable each is over decades.
  • Whether any prevents later osteoarthritis.

The story, step by step

  1. 1. Why it is hard ()
  2. 2. Marrow stimulation ()
  3. 3. Moving real cartilage ()
  4. 4. Cell-based repair ()
  5. 5. Choosing ()
What the evidence labels mean
GuidelineAn official recommendation from an expert group after weighing all the evidence.
Review of many studiesCombines the results of many studies (a systematic review or meta-analysis).
Randomized trialPeople were randomly given a treatment or a comparison, the best way to test cause and effect.
Large observational studyFollows many people over time. Shows strong links, but not always cause and effect.
Small or early studyA small study, case series, or first results. Needs to be confirmed.
Lab or animal studyDone in cells or animals. May not apply to people.
Part 1 of 5

The repair problem

Review of many studies

What happens

Cartilage does not heal.

What the research shows

  • Articular cartilage has no blood supply, no nerves and very few cells, and those cells divide slowly and barely move.
  • A defect that does not reach bone receives almost no healing response at all.
  • A defect that reaches bone does bleed, and that produces repair tissue, but fibrocartilage rather than the original hyaline cartilage.
  • Fibrocartilage is mechanically inferior: less resilient, less smooth, and less durable under repeated load.
  • The goal of every technique is therefore either to bring in real cartilage from elsewhere or to persuade the body to make something closer to the original.
  • Results are better for small defects, in younger patients, in non-weight-bearing or less loaded areas, and in joints that are otherwise healthy and well aligned.

Why it matters

That no operation produces normal cartilage is the fact that should frame every discussion about these procedures.

What's still uncertain

  • Whether tissue engineering will solve this.

Read more

Next: Marrow stimulation

Part 2 of 5

Microfracture and drilling

Review of many studies

What happens

Letting the marrow do it.

What the research shows

  • The damaged cartilage is cleared back to a stable rim, and small holes are made in the exposed bone with an awl or drill.
  • Marrow cells and blood enter the defect and form a clot that matures into repair tissue over months.
  • The result is fibrocartilage. It can be functional and comfortable, particularly for small defects, but it is less durable than the original.
  • It is a single, relatively simple arthroscopic procedure and is often tried first for small defects.
  • Rehabilitation is long despite the simplicity of the operation: typically weeks of restricted weight-bearing and months before full activity, because the repair tissue matures slowly.
  • Results tend to deteriorate over time, particularly in larger defects and more active people, which has narrowed its use.
  • A variant uses a scaffold or membrane over the treated area to improve the quality of the repair tissue.

Why it matters

A simple operation with a long recovery is a common source of frustration here, because people expect the recovery to match the size of the procedure.

What's still uncertain

  • How long results last.
  • Whether scaffolds improve the repair.

Read more

Next: Moving real cartilage

Part 3 of 5

Autograft and allograft

Review of many studies

What happens

Transplanting the surface.

What the research shows

  • Osteochondral autograft transfer takes one or more cylindrical plugs of bone and cartilage from a lightly loaded part of the same joint and press-fits them into the defect.
  • It transplants genuine hyaline cartilage with its bone attached, which is its main advantage, and the bone heals to bone reliably.
  • It is limited by how much can be taken without causing problems at the donor site, so it suits small to moderate defects.
  • Matching the curvature of the joint surface matters: a plug sitting proud or sunk changes how load is carried.
  • Osteochondral allograft uses tissue from a donor, which removes the donor-site limit and suits large defects, including those with substantial bone loss.
  • Allograft tissue is fresh-stored, so availability and timing can be constraints, and size matching is needed.
  • Disease transmission risk is very low but not zero, and the cartilage cells in the graft are not rejected in the way other transplanted tissue is.

Why it matters

The autograft is limited by supply and the allograft by availability, which is often what decides between them in practice.

What's still uncertain

  • How these compare long-term.
  • How donor-site problems affect outcomes.

Read more

Next: Cell-based repair

Part 4 of 5

Growing cartilage cells

Review of many studies

What happens

Two operations, months apart.

What the research shows

  • In autologous chondrocyte implantation, a small sample of cartilage is taken arthroscopically, and the cells are grown in a laboratory over several weeks.
  • In a second operation, the cells are implanted into the defect, held under a membrane or on a scaffold in newer versions.
  • The repair tissue is closer to hyaline cartilage than fibrocartilage, though not identical to the original.
  • It suits larger defects in younger patients, and is used when other options are unsuitable or have failed.
  • It requires two operations, a gap of weeks between them, and a long, carefully staged rehabilitation of up to a year before return to sport.
  • Cost and availability vary considerably between health systems.
  • Where there is significant bone loss under the cartilage, bone grafting is combined with the procedure, since the cells need a sound foundation.

Why it matters

The two-stage structure, the cost and the year-long rehabilitation are the practical constraints more often than the surgical result.

What's still uncertain

  • How cell-based repair compares with grafting.
  • Whether newer scaffold versions improve results.

Read more

Next: Choosing

Part 5 of 5

What the decision turns on

Review of many studies

What happens

Factors, and questions to ask.

What the research shows

  • Defect size: small defects suit marrow stimulation or autograft; larger ones suit allograft or cell-based repair.
  • Depth: significant bone loss points toward techniques that replace bone as well as cartilage.
  • Location: weight-bearing areas demand more durable solutions.
  • Age and activity: younger, more active people place higher demands and generally do better with techniques that restore real cartilage.
  • The state of the rest of the joint: alignment, meniscal status and ligament stability all have to be addressed, or any repair will fail.
  • Previous surgery: failed marrow stimulation makes later cell-based repair less successful, which is an argument against reflexively starting with the simplest option in a large defect.
  • Reasonable questions: what will this produce, how long is the rehabilitation, what happens if it fails, what are your results, and what are the alternatives.

Why it matters

Correcting alignment or meniscal problems at the same time is often what determines whether a cartilage repair survives, and it is easy to overlook.

What's still uncertain

  • Which algorithm gives the best outcomes.
  • Whether early choice of technique matters.

Read more

More plain-language reading

See something wrong or unclear on this page? Suggest a correction. OwieClear is for education only and isn't medical advice.