Dialysis and transplant: what to expect
Last reviewed November 17, 2026. OwieClear editorial team. Waiting for clinician review. Not medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your own care.
Most people with CKD never need any of this. For those who do, the decisions are made far better with months of preparation than in a hospital bed.
There are four paths, not two, and conservative care is a legitimate choice rather than a refusal of treatment.
Related pages: Chronic kidney disease
The bottom line
- Kidney replacement is usually considered as eGFR approaches 15, guided by symptoms rather than the number alone.
- Haemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis have broadly similar survival; the differences are practical.
- Transplant offers better survival and quality of life than dialysis for suitable candidates.
- A pre-emptive transplant, before dialysis starts, gives the best outcomes.
- Conservative management without dialysis is an appropriate choice for some, particularly frail older people.
- The best timing to start dialysis.
- How to expand access to home dialysis and to transplantation.
- How to predict who will benefit little from dialysis.
The story, step by step
What the evidence labels mean
What triggers the conversation
What happens
Symptoms, not a threshold alone.
What the research shows
- Planning usually begins when eGFR falls below about 20, which gives time to prepare.
- Starting is guided by symptoms and complications rather than by the number alone: nausea, poor appetite, fluid overload, uncontrollable potassium or acidosis.
- Trials comparing earlier with later starts found no survival advantage to starting early in people without symptoms.
- Education about the options should happen well before any of it is needed, because the choice affects how the access is created.
- Late, unplanned starts, often via an emergency admission and a neck catheter, carry worse outcomes and are common.
- This is one of the strongest arguments for early nephrology referral.
Why it matters
The difference between a planned and an unplanned start is large and almost entirely about how early the conversation happened.
What's still uncertain
- The optimal eGFR and symptom threshold for starting.
- How to reduce the rate of unplanned starts.
Read more
- NIDDK: Kidney failure and treatment choicesGovernment
- KDIGO: CKD evaluation and management guidelineNonprofit
- MedlinePlus: Kidney failureGovernment
Next: Haemodialysis
The machine most people picture
What happens
Blood cleaned outside the body.
What the research shows
- Blood is pumped through a filter that removes waste and excess fluid, then returned.
- In a clinic it is typically three sessions a week, around four hours each, plus travel. Home haemodialysis allows more frequent, shorter or overnight sessions.
- Access is usually an arteriovenous fistula, a surgically joined artery and vein in the arm, created months in advance because it needs time to mature.
- A graft is an alternative where veins are unsuitable. A tunnelled catheter is used when dialysis is needed before access is ready, and carries higher infection risk.
- Common effects include fatigue after sessions, low blood pressure, cramps and a restricted fluid allowance.
- The fistula arm is protected: no blood pressure cuffs, no blood draws, and no tight sleeves on that side.
Why it matters
The fistula is why the conversation needs to start months early. Access planned in advance is the difference between a routine start and an emergency one.
What's still uncertain
- Whether more frequent dialysis improves long-term outcomes.
- How to increase home haemodialysis uptake.
Read more
- NIDDK: HemodialysisGovernment
- MedlinePlus: DialysisGovernment
- NIDDK: Kidney failure and treatment choicesGovernment
Next: Peritoneal dialysis
The home option
What happens
The abdominal lining as the filter.
What the research shows
- Fluid is run into the abdominal cavity through a soft catheter. The peritoneal membrane allows waste and fluid to cross into it, and the fluid is then drained.
- It is done at home, either as several manual exchanges a day or overnight by a machine while sleeping.
- It allows more independence, easier travel and a less restricted diet and fluid allowance than clinic haemodialysis.
- It preserves remaining kidney function somewhat better in the early period.
- The main risk is peritonitis, infection of the abdominal lining, which is why sterile technique is taught carefully.
- It is not suitable after extensive abdominal surgery or with certain hernias, and its effectiveness can decline after some years, often prompting a switch.
Why it matters
Survival between the two dialysis types is broadly comparable. The decision is mostly about how someone wants to live, which makes it genuinely theirs to make.
What's still uncertain
- Why uptake varies so much between countries and centres.
- How long peritoneal membrane function typically lasts.
Read more
- NIDDK: Peritoneal dialysisGovernment
- MedlinePlus: DialysisGovernment
- NIDDK: Kidney failure and treatment choicesGovernment
Next: Transplant
The best outcome where possible
What happens
Better survival, better life, still an operation.
What the research shows
- A transplanted kidney does the full job, including the hormone functions that dialysis does not replace.
- Survival and quality of life are better than on dialysis for suitable candidates, across most age groups.
- A pre-emptive transplant, performed before dialysis is needed, gives the best results, which is another reason for early referral.
- Living donation gives better graft survival than deceased donation and avoids the waiting list, which in the United States commonly runs to several years.
- Lifelong immunosuppression is required, with risks of infection and of certain cancers, and regular monitoring.
- Transplants do not last forever. Many function for well over a decade, and some people return to dialysis or receive a second transplant.
Why it matters
Transplant is a treatment, not a cure, and it is still clearly the best available outcome for most people who are eligible.
What's still uncertain
- How to reduce inequity in access to transplantation.
- How to extend graft survival beyond current averages.
Read more
- NIDDK: Kidney transplantGovernment
- MedlinePlus: Kidney transplantationGovernment
- National Kidney FoundationNonprofit
Next: Conservative care
Choosing not to dialyse
What happens
A treatment plan, not an absence of one.
What the research shows
- Conservative kidney management treats symptoms, anaemia, fluid and acidosis without dialysis.
- For some frail older adults with multiple other conditions, dialysis adds little survival time and can reduce independence and quality of life considerably.
- The survival difference narrows substantially with age and frailty, and for some it disappears.
- This option should be presented alongside the others rather than as a last resort or a failure.
- It involves active medical care, symptom control and planning, often with palliative care alongside, and people can change their minds.
- Advance care planning, including what matters most to the person, belongs in this conversation.
Why it matters
Naming conservative care as a real option changes the conversation from whether to accept treatment into which treatment fits this person's life.
What's still uncertain
- How to predict who will benefit little from dialysis.
- How to present this option without implying care is being withdrawn.