Is it arthritis, or something else in the hand?
Last reviewed November 17, 2026. OwieClear editorial team. Waiting for clinician review. Not medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your own care.
Hands develop a lot of different problems and several of them feel broadly similar: pain, stiffness, weakness, a lump. They are managed very differently.
Most can be separated by where exactly it hurts, what makes it worse, and what the lump feels like.
Related pages: Osteoarthritis of the hand
The bottom line
- Osteoarthritis causes hard bony lumps at specific joints; other conditions produce different lumps in different places.
- Carpal tunnel causes numbness and tingling, not joint pain.
- De Quervain's tendon pain sits above the thumb base joint and hurts on wrist movement.
- Rheumatoid arthritis favours the knuckles and wrists and causes long morning stiffness.
- A hot, very swollen single joint needs same-day assessment.
- How often these conditions coexist.
- Why they cluster in the same people.
- How best to distinguish thumb base arthritis from De Quervain's.
The story, step by step
What the evidence labels mean
Trigger finger and De Quervain's
What happens
Tendons, not joints.
What the research shows
- Trigger finger is a thickened tendon catching in its sheath. The finger clicks, locks in a bent position, or has to be straightened with the other hand, and is often worst in the morning.
- It is tender in the palm at the base of the finger rather than at the knuckle or the finger joints.
- It is treated with splinting, steroid injection or a small operation to release the sheath, and is more common in people with diabetes.
- De Quervain's tenosynovitis affects the tendons running to the thumb on the thumb side of the wrist, just above the thumb base joint.
- It hurts on wrist movement and on gripping with the thumb tucked in, and is common after a new repetitive activity or after childbirth.
- It is treated with a thumb spica splint, activity change, injection or surgery.
- The main confusion is between De Quervain's and thumb base arthritis, because both cause thumb-side pain. The tendon problem sits further up the wrist and hurts on movement rather than on pinch pressure.
Why it matters
Locating the pain within a couple of centimetres is what separates these, which is why clinicians press in several specific spots.
What's still uncertain
- How often the two thumb conditions coexist.
Read more
- MedlinePlus: Finger injuries and disordersGovernment
- MedlinePlus: Wrist injuries and disordersGovernment
- MedlinePlus: Repetitive motion disordersGovernment
Next: Nerve problems
Carpal tunnel and the rest
What happens
Numbness is the clue.
What the research shows
- Carpal tunnel syndrome is compression of the median nerve at the wrist. It causes numbness, tingling and burning in the thumb, index, middle and half the ring finger.
- It is characteristically worse at night and wakes people, who shake the hand to relieve it.
- It causes weakness and clumsiness, and in long-standing cases wasting of the muscle at the base of the thumb.
- It is not joint pain, and it does not cause bony lumps, although it commonly coexists with hand osteoarthritis.
- It is treated with night splints, activity change, injection or surgical release, and nerve conduction studies confirm it when needed.
- Compression of the ulnar nerve at the elbow causes numbness in the little and ring fingers instead.
- Numbness in a glove distribution, in both hands, points toward a general nerve problem such as diabetic neuropathy.
Why it matters
Numbness and tingling are nerve symptoms, not arthritis symptoms, and a hand with both usually has both conditions.
What's still uncertain
- Why carpal tunnel and hand osteoarthritis coexist so often.
Read more
- MedlinePlus: Carpal tunnel syndromeGovernment
- MedlinePlus: Finger injuries and disordersGovernment
- MedlinePlus: OsteoarthritisGovernment
Next: Lumps
What the lump is
What happens
Different lumps, different places.
What the research shows
- Heberden's and Bouchard's nodes are hard, fixed, at the finger joints, and develop over years.
- Ganglion cysts are smooth, rubbery, often on the back of the wrist or at the base of a finger, and can change size over weeks. They are harmless and often need no treatment.
- Mucous cysts are small fluid-filled swellings at the joints nearest the nails, associated with osteoarthritis there, and can ridge the nail.
- Dupuytren's disease produces firm cords and nodules in the palm, pulling fingers, usually the ring and little, into a bend that cannot be straightened. It affects the fascia, not the joints.
- Rheumatoid nodules are firm lumps near the elbow or over pressure points in rheumatoid arthritis.
- Gouty tophi are chalky lumps that can appear around finger joints and the ear in long-standing gout.
- Any lump that grows steadily, is fixed to bone, or is painful at night deserves assessment rather than assumption.
Why it matters
Where the lump is and whether it is hard or rubbery usually settles it without any test.
What's still uncertain
- Why Dupuytren's and osteoarthritis sometimes coexist.
Read more
- MedlinePlus: Finger injuries and disordersGovernment
- MedlinePlus: Wrist injuries and disordersGovernment
- MedlinePlus: OsteoarthritisGovernment
Next: Other arthritis
Rheumatoid, psoriatic, gout
What happens
The ones that need different treatment.
What the research shows
- Rheumatoid arthritis favours the knuckles, the middle finger joints and the wrists, is symmetrical, and spares the joints nearest the nails. Morning stiffness lasts an hour or more.
- Its swelling is soft, warm and boggy rather than hard, and it comes with fatigue and sometimes fever and weight loss.
- It needs early specialist treatment to prevent joint damage, which is why suspecting it is urgent rather than routine.
- Psoriatic arthritis can affect the joints nearest the nails, overlapping with osteoarthritis, but usually comes with nail pitting or separation, skin psoriasis, or a whole swollen finger.
- Gout can affect finger joints, particularly in older women on diuretics, and sometimes appears on top of existing osteoarthritic nodes, which is a classic trap.
- Calcium pyrophosphate deposition causes attacks resembling gout, often in the wrist, with calcium visible in cartilage on X-ray.
- A single joint that is hot, markedly swollen and severely painful needs same-day assessment for infection whatever the background.
Why it matters
Gout appearing on top of existing nodes is worth knowing about, because the sudden worsening of a known arthritic joint gets written off as a flare.
What's still uncertain
- How often gout is missed in nodal hand osteoarthritis.
- How best to shorten time to rheumatoid diagnosis.
Read more
- MedlinePlus: Rheumatoid arthritisGovernment
- MedlinePlus: GoutGovernment
- NIAMS: Rheumatoid arthritisGovernment