How articular cartilage breaks down, step by step
Last reviewed November 17, 2026. OwieClear editorial team. Waiting for clinician review. Not medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your own care.
Cartilage looks inert, and it is not. It is maintained by a sparse population of cells that constantly rebuild the material around them, and osteoarthritis is what happens when that balance tips the wrong way.
Following the process from the molecule to the ache explains several things that otherwise seem arbitrary, including why bone spurs form and why damaged cartilage does not hurt.
Related pages: Osteoarthritis in several joints (wear-and-tear arthritis)
The bottom line
- Cartilage is a water-rich gel of collagen and proteoglycans maintained by chondrocytes.
- In osteoarthritis, breakdown enzymes outpace rebuilding.
- The bone underneath thickens and grows spurs at the joint margins.
- Cartilage itself has no nerves; the pain comes from other tissues.
- Adult cartilage has very limited capacity to repair itself.
- Which event starts the cascade.
- Whether the process can be halted with a drug.
- Why repair fails so completely in adult cartilage.
The story, step by step
- 1. The material ()
- 2. The tipping point ()
- 3. The bone responds ()
- 4. Where the pain comes from ()
- 5. Why repair fails ()
What the evidence labels mean
What cartilage is made of
What happens
A pressurised gel in a collagen mesh.
What the research shows
- Articular cartilage is roughly 65 to 80 percent water. The rest is a scaffold of type II collagen fibres and large molecules called proteoglycans, chiefly aggrecan.
- Proteoglycans carry a strong negative charge, which draws water in. The collagen mesh resists that swelling, so the tissue sits under internal pressure.
- That pressurised arrangement is what lets cartilage take load: under compression, water is squeezed out slowly and the tissue stiffens, then it rehydrates when the load is removed.
- Chondrocytes, the only cells in cartilage, make up a few percent of its volume. They maintain the matrix around them.
- There are no blood vessels, no lymphatics and no nerves. Nutrients diffuse in from synovial fluid, driven by the pumping action of movement.
- This is why prolonged immobility is bad for cartilage and why loading it in a reasonable range is good for it.
Why it matters
The absence of a blood supply explains both the limited healing and the dependence on movement, which is the single most actionable fact in this whole chain.
What's still uncertain
- How quickly cartilage composition changes with inactivity.
Read more
- NIAMS: OsteoarthritisGovernment
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons: OrthoInfoNonprofit
- MedlinePlus: OsteoarthritisGovernment
Next: The tipping point
Breakdown outpaces repair
What happens
An imbalance in the chondrocyte's work.
What the research shows
- Chondrocytes continuously degrade and replace matrix. In osteoarthritis they shift toward a degradative and inflammatory programme.
- They produce more matrix metalloproteinases and aggrecanases, enzymes that cut collagen and aggrecan, and more inflammatory signals such as interleukin-1 and tumour necrosis factor.
- Aggrecan is lost first. Without its charge drawing water in, the tissue loses its stiffness and takes load badly, which damages the collagen mesh.
- Once type II collagen is cut, the damage is effectively irreversible: adult chondrocytes cannot rebuild that network.
- The surface roughens, then fissures, then wears through to bone in places.
- Chondrocytes also attempt repair, multiplying into clusters and laying down matrix, but the repair tissue is disorganised and mechanically inferior.
Why it matters
The repair attempt is part of the problem, which is why osteoarthritis is called an active disease rather than passive erosion.
What's still uncertain
- Whether blocking these enzymes helps in people.
- What triggers the shift in chondrocyte behaviour.
Read more
- NIAMS: OsteoarthritisGovernment
- CDC: OsteoarthritisGovernment
- Arthritis FoundationNonprofit
Next: The bone responds
Sclerosis, cysts and spurs
What happens
The layer underneath changes too.
What the research shows
- Beneath the cartilage is subchondral bone. As the cartilage above thins, this bone takes more load and responds by becoming denser and harder, which is subchondral sclerosis.
- Dense bone is stiffer and absorbs shock less well, so it passes more load back to the remaining cartilage. That is another self-reinforcing loop.
- Small fluid-filled cavities, subchondral cysts, can form, probably where joint fluid is forced into microfractures.
- At the joint margins, where cartilage meets bone, new bone and cartilage grow outward into osteophytes, the bone spurs seen on X-rays.
- Spurs are usually read as a sign of osteoarthritis rather than a cause of pain, although they can restrict movement or press on nerves in the spine.
- Bone marrow lesions, bruise-like areas seen on MRI, are among the features most consistently associated with pain.
Why it matters
Spurs are what produce the visible knobby fingers of hand osteoarthritis, which is why the bumps are hard rather than puffy.
What's still uncertain
- Whether treating bone marrow lesions reduces pain.
- Whether bone changes precede cartilage loss.
Read more
- NIAMS: OsteoarthritisGovernment
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons: OrthoInfoNonprofit
- MedlinePlus: OsteoarthritisGovernment
Not the cartilage
What happens
Several tissues, none of them the worn surface.
What the research shows
- Cartilage has no nerve supply, so wearing it away is not itself painful. This is why joints can look badly damaged on X-ray and barely hurt.
- Pain-sensitive structures in and around a joint include the subchondral bone, the synovium and joint capsule, the ligaments, the periosteum covering bone, and the surrounding muscles and tendons.
- Low-grade synovitis, inflammation of the joint lining, is present in many osteoarthritic joints and correlates with pain and with swelling after activity.
- Stretching of the capsule by swelling or bone growth, and raised pressure inside bone, both produce pain.
- In longer-standing osteoarthritis the nervous system itself changes, becoming more sensitive to signals from the joint. This central sensitisation contributes to pain that is out of proportion to the damage.
- Sleep disturbance, low mood and inactivity all amplify pain, which is why they are treated as part of the condition rather than as separate problems.
Why it matters
The poor match between X-ray appearance and pain is one of the most consistent findings in this field, and it is the reason treatment is aimed at symptoms and function rather than at images.
What's still uncertain
- How much of chronic osteoarthritis pain is centrally driven.
- Why X-ray severity and pain match so poorly.
Read more
- NIAMS: OsteoarthritisGovernment
- MedlinePlus: OsteoarthritisGovernment
- Arthritis FoundationNonprofit
Next: Why repair fails
The healing problem
What happens
Adult cartilage is a poor healer.
What the research shows
- With no blood supply, cartilage cannot mount the normal injury response of bleeding, clotting and cell recruitment that other tissues use.
- Chondrocytes divide slowly and move very little, so they cannot migrate into a defect to fill it.
- Damage that reaches through to bone does bleed, and that produces repair tissue, but it is fibrocartilage: tougher, less springy, and less durable than the original.
- This is the basis of surgical techniques such as microfracture, which deliberately breach the bone to generate that repair tissue.
- Cartilage transplantation and cell-based repair techniques exist and are mainly used for isolated defects in younger people, not for widespread osteoarthritis.
- No drug has been shown convincingly to regenerate cartilage or halt progression in people, despite a long list of candidates.
Why it matters
Treatments promising cartilage regeneration should be approached sceptically, because this is an area with a great deal of marketing and little proven benefit.
What's still uncertain
- Whether cell or gene therapy will change this.
- How durable cartilage repair procedures are.
Read more
- NIAMS: OsteoarthritisGovernment
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons: OrthoInfoNonprofit
- MedlinePlus: OsteoarthritisGovernment