How cracks form in cartilage and bone, step by step
Last reviewed November 17, 2026. OwieClear editorial team. Waiting for clinician review. Not medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your own care.
Osteochondritis dissecans starts underneath the joint surface, not on it. The cartilage is a passenger: it cracks and separates because the bone holding it has failed.
The honest position is that the trigger is not fully understood. Several mechanisms contribute and which dominates probably varies between cases.
Related pages: Osteochondritis dissecans (loose piece of bone in a joint)
The bottom line
- The problem starts in the bone beneath the cartilage, not in the cartilage.
- Repetitive microtrauma and interrupted blood supply are the main proposed mechanisms.
- The cartilage cracks later, as the bone beneath it fails to support it.
- A fragment progresses from stable, to partly separated, to fully loose.
- The trigger is not fully understood and is probably multifactorial.
- What actually initiates the lesion.
- Why specific spots in specific joints are affected.
- How much is genetic.
The story, step by step
What the evidence labels mean
Subchondral bone
What happens
What it does.
What the research shows
- Under the articular cartilage is a thin plate of dense bone, the subchondral bone plate, and under that spongy bone with a blood supply.
- This layer supports the cartilage mechanically and supplies it indirectly with nutrients.
- Cartilage has no blood vessels of its own, so it depends on synovial fluid and on the health of the bone beneath it.
- The blood supply to these areas comes through terminal vessels, meaning there are few alternative routes if one is interrupted.
- In growing bone, this region is undergoing active remodelling and has a particular vascular arrangement, which may explain the age pattern.
- If the bone here dies or fails, the cartilage above loses its foundation even though the cartilage itself started healthy.
Why it matters
The terminal blood supply is the key vulnerability: there is no second route if the first one fails.
What's still uncertain
- How the blood supply to these areas is organised.
- Why specific sites are watershed areas.
Read more
- NIAMS: Osteochondritis dissecansGovernment
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons: OrthoInfoNonprofit
- MedlinePlus: Bone diseasesGovernment
Next: The proposed triggers
Four competing mechanisms
What happens
No single agreed answer.
What the research shows
- Repetitive microtrauma is the most widely supported explanation: repeated impact or torsion causes microfractures in the subchondral bone faster than they can heal.
- Ischaemia, a loss of blood supply to a small area, causing the bone to die. The evidence here is mixed, and histology does not always show the expected necrosis.
- A genetic contribution, suggested by families with multiple affected members and by cases affecting several joints at once. No single gene explains most cases.
- Abnormal ossification during growth, where an area of the developing bone forms abnormally and remains weak.
- A single significant injury is sometimes blamed, and may unmask or worsen an existing lesion rather than create it.
- Most likely several of these interact: a susceptible area, repetitive loading, and a blood supply that cannot keep up with repair.
Why it matters
The honest summary is that a plausible mechanism exists for each of these and none of them explains every case.
What's still uncertain
- Which mechanism dominates.
- Whether the categories are even distinct.
Read more
- NIAMS: Osteochondritis dissecansGovernment
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons: OrthoInfoNonprofit
- NIAMS: Sports injuriesGovernment
Next: The crack forms
From bone to cartilage
What happens
The sequence.
What the research shows
- The earliest change is in the bone: microfractures, oedema and a zone of bone that is not healing normally.
- At this stage the cartilage above is intact, sometimes softened or thickened, and the joint surface looks normal from inside.
- A line of fibrous tissue develops between the affected area and the healthy bone around it. This is the plane along which separation can occur.
- As the bone beneath fails to support it, the cartilage over the lesion cracks, usually at the edges first.
- Fluid can then get between the fragment and the bone, which further prevents healing and shows up on MRI as a bright line behind the fragment.
- The fragment becomes partly detached, hinged at one edge, and then fully detached as a loose body.
- Once detached, the crater left behind fills with fibrous tissue rather than cartilage, which is mechanically inferior.
Why it matters
The fluid line behind a fragment on MRI is the finding that most often decides between non-surgical and surgical treatment.
What's still uncertain
- What determines whether a lesion progresses.
- Whether the fibrous line can be reversed.
Read more
- NIAMS: Osteochondritis dissecansGovernment
- American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons: OrthoInfoNonprofit
- MedlinePlus: Osteochondritis dissecansGovernment
Next: What the fragment does
Loose bodies
What happens
A piece of bone in a moving joint.
What the research shows
- A fully detached fragment is a loose body. It can be cartilage alone, or cartilage with bone attached.
- It moves around the joint and can lodge between the surfaces, which jams the joint. That is mechanical locking, and it is usually sudden and alarming.
- It can also catch intermittently, producing clicking, catching, or the joint giving way.
- A loose body can grind against healthy cartilage, damaging it, which turns a single defect into more widespread damage.
- Loose bodies can grow slowly, because they take nutrition from synovial fluid, and can ossify.
- Some become embedded in the joint lining and stop causing symptoms, which is why not every loose body on an X-ray needs removing.
- The crater left in the joint surface is the more serious long-term problem, because it concentrates load at its edges and promotes osteoarthritis.
Why it matters
Removing a loose body relieves the locking but does not repair the crater, which is why the operation is often more than a tidy-up.
What's still uncertain
- How often loose bodies cause further damage.
- Which craters need repairing.